Political Quotes

David Cay Johnston: On this particular issue, let me--the point is the fact that they have said it does not make it so. I believe it is…

On the recordJuly 11, 1995
On this particular issue, let me--the point is the fact that they have said it does not make it so. I believe it is clear. Now, what I believe also is that this language would really put an ambiguity into it because in the event of a conflict the statute under which the rule is promulgated shall govern. Now, the statute under which the rule is promulgated did not require risk assessment, did not require cost-benefit analysis, did not require that you go through any of those procedural hoops. I could make the strong argument that this would say that that rule under which it was promulgated, if at the time it was promulgated satisfied those rules, then that governs and that this statute, the petition process, the look-back process, is taken out of the picture; it is no longer valid. Does the Senator see what I am talking about?
Said by
David Cay Johnston
West Virginia

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the implications of language in a regulatory statute.

Share

More from David Cay Johnston

Jul 31, 1996

If I may answer that, because the Senator is a very thoughtful Senator and it is a fair question. First of all, let me say, on the issue of reprocessing, you would need a central facility for reprocessing anyway. So that does not solve the…

govinfo.gov
Jul 31, 1996

The decision of the court of appeals makes clear that they have a vested right to the title passing as of the time that the nuclear repository is built and not until that time, but they have the duty to dispose of the waste January 31…

govinfo.gov
Sep 3, 1996

I rise today to speak to the merits of a program that has done great work in the field of medicine. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, or ATSDR, funded through the Environmental Protection Agency, has addressed the…

govinfo.gov
Jul 29, 1996

I simply rise in support of the position of the Senator from New Mexico. I was here several years ago speaking in favor of the continuation of the testing program, because I thought it was important for both reliability and safety. The…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation