Bob Goodlatte: “This is a good piece of legislation. I urge my colleagues to support it and support our law enforcement officers. I…”

I do think they have jumped the guardrails.

For all the reasons cited by my distinguished colleagues, yes.

Right, but the sale of the information to the government puts the government in the picture as well and the Fourth Amendment is directed at the government not obtaining information without showing probable cause, without providing a…

I think a great first step would be to pass the Fourth Amendment's Not For Sale Act that's been introduced by Chair Nadler.