Political Quotes

On the recordDecember 8, 2003
Then they are going to come back in 10 years and say, see, Medicare does not work. Of course it does not work when the insurance company insures you when you are healthy and then taxpayers and Medicare get you when you are old and sick. Of course it is going to work that way. That is the irony of all this. I hear my friends on the other side of the aisle over and over tell us that seniors, that the private sector can do it better, that government is this huge bureaucracy, that Medicare is inefficient and bloated, that nimble, quick-on-its-feet Medicare, the private insurance system can do it better. So, okay, if that is the case, why, then, does Medicare have lower administrative costs, why does Medicare have lower marketing costs, lower salaries and all that? But if you accept that they can let them compete, so why are we giving the Medicare HMOs $20 billion and say, yeah, of course one can compete if we give you $20 extra billion, but if the playing field were really level it is clear that the public system wins. That is why 38 years ago in the end Medicare was created. Because in 1965 when President Johnson and Democratic majorities in both Houses, because, as we said, almost no Republicans in either House voted for this bill to create Medicare, in those days half of America's seniors did not have insurance. Why? Because the private insurance market did not find seniors attractive.
Said by
Sherrod Brown
Democratic · Ohio

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the effectiveness and funding of Medicare in relation to private insurance.

Share

More from Sherrod Brown

Feb 10, 2025

It’s heartbreaking to think that all this time these products could have been harmful and it’s enraging that now we have so much evidence that we need to take action and it’s not happening.

cnn.com
May 12, 2026

I am honored to stand with my CBC colleagues in this fight as we stand up for the people we represent. For decades, the far right has sold this country a lie, a lie that racism ended in 1965, a lie that discrimination is ancient history…

govinfo.gov
Dec 19, 2024

today I ask my colleagues to join me in honoring our administrative team. Their hard work and dedication make our day-to-day operations possible. They are the glue that holds our office together, from making sure staff have the technology…

govinfo.gov
Aug 26, 2026

All across Ohio, I hear from small business owners, farmers, and hardworking families who are getting crushed by reckless tariffs that Jon Husted supports.

huffpost.com

Other voices in this conversation