Political Quotes

Joseph Knollenberg: “I again thank the gentleman. Mr. Chairman, by its terms the McCarran-Ferguson Act renders any Federal statute…”

On the recordJune 25, 1996
I again thank the gentleman. Mr. Chairman, by its terms the McCarran-Ferguson Act renders any Federal statute inapplicable to the activities of insurance companies, if, one, the Federal statute does not specifically relate to insurance; two, the challenged activity constitutes the business of insurance; and, three, the Federal statute would invalidate, impair or supersede State insurance law. An examination of these factors suggests that the application of the Fair Housing Act to property insurance practices is barred by the McCarran-Ferguson Act. As I previously stated, the Fair Housing Act makes no mention of property insurance. Secondly, the pricing, underwriting and marketing of property insurance policies clearly constitutes the business of insurance.
Said by
Joseph Knollenberg
Republican · Michigan

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the implications of the McCarran-Ferguson Act on the Fair Housing Act during a committee meeting.

Share

More from Joseph Knollenberg

Jun 14, 2006

Every one of these projects relative to the gentleman's comments, must relate to the eligibility of the CDBG program. Every single one. We don't waive the requirements. In fact, to show how worthwhile we think these projects are, for the…

govinfo.gov
Jun 13, 2006

HOPE VI was intended to demolish 100,000 units of severely distressed public housing units, and the program has accomplished that goal. However, there is currently $80 million in unobligated funds going back as far as 10 years-plus. And…

govinfo.gov
Jun 14, 2006

If you withdraw the amendment, I am prepared to work with you any way that I can, but the amendment would have to be withdrawn, so I am just asking for a guarantee that the amendment will be withdrawn.

govinfo.gov
Jun 14, 2006

Economic development initiatives, EDI grants, are targeted grants designed to address local economic development needs. As representatives of these communities, it is our responsibility to ensure that these needs when present are…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation