this amendment is one of a series of amendments that I intend to offer to end the practice of providing Federal benefits to illegal aliens. Each of these amendments will have the effect of stemming the huge drain on the Federal budget caused by opening the Federal treasury without restriction to people who have violated the laws of our country by coming here. In this case, my amendment will also eliminate one of the largest unfunded Federal mandates in existence. This mandate has come about through a combination of the Player versus Doe Supreme Court decision and a lack of congressional policy in this area. In 1982, the Supreme Court decided by a 5 to 4 vote that, in the absence of congressional policy to the contrary, States must provide a free education to illegal aliens. Let me repeat that, Madam Chairman. This Supreme Court decision was not only decided by one vote, in a more liberal Supreme Court than we have today, but even by its terms, it is a mandate on the States, not the Federal Government. And, as is obvious to anyone who actually reads the majority opinion in this case, the only reason the State of Texas was not allowed to make the distinction between citizens and legal residents on the one hand, and illegal aliens on the other, was because Congress had made no such distinction.
Dana Rohrabacher: “this amendment is one of a series of amendments that I intend to offer to end the practice of providing Federal benefits…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing amendments to end federal benefits for illegal aliens during a House floor debate.
Share
More from Dana Rohrabacher
Yes, thank you much, Chairman King, Ranking Member Cohen, and other members of the subcommittee.
What we seem to be having now and what you're describing is that the Chinese Government is going through another period where it is clamping down in order to stamp out those forces in society, especially those containing religion like the…
I remember, like, one of the things when I first got here was the Clinton administration's insistence on spending what was the equivalent of $50 million providing fuel for North Korea, and it had just the opposite impact.
Let me start by thanking the thousands of firefighters who, each year, put their lives at risk to battle wildfires like those that have plagued California and other western States. We owe it to them, as well as to the American people, to…





