Political Quotes

Jeff Duncan: regardless of how one feels about the Terri Schiavo case, and regardless of whether one is a liberal or a conservative…

On the recordApril 6, 2005
regardless of how one feels about the Terri Schiavo case, and regardless of whether one is a liberal or a conservative, everyone should be concerned that the judiciary seems to be setting itself up as a type of superlegislature. Our Founding Fathers clearly did not mean for the judicial branch to be superior to or more powerful than the legislative and executive branches. A Member of the other body, former State supreme court justice, the gentleman from Texas (Mr. Cornyn), made some very serious charges on the floor of the Senate Monday. He said, ``It causes a lot of people great distress to see judges use the authority they have been given to make raw political or ideological decisions.'' He added that ``sometimes the Supreme Court has taken on this role as a policymaker rather than an enforcer of political decisions made by elected representatives of the people.'' The reason people on both sides of the political spectrum should be concerned about this judicial power grab is that the political pendulum swings. Sometimes conservatives control legislative bodies; sometimes liberals do. Would liberals someday want conservative judges overruling their legislation? The Schiavo bill was very narrowly drawn to apply to just that case at the request or insistence of more liberal Members of both the House and Senate.
Said by
Jeff Duncan
Republican · South Carolina

Editor's note · Context

Discussing concerns over judicial power in relation to the Terri Schiavo case.

Share

More from Jeff Duncan

Jun 25, 2024

This election is going to be determined by a group of folks that don't like the - almost every one of Joe Biden's policies, or a majority of those policies. But they just are going to have to wake up and feel like he's a safer option to…

transcripts.cnn.com
Sep 27, 2023

We are already beginning to see the consequences of poor energy policy.

congress.gov
Mar 22, 2024

We are showing how misguided this $27 billion green bank is, and the gentleman from Pennsylvania (Mr. Joyce) knows about fossil fuel production and what this would mean to the great State of Pennsylvania that produces a lot of energy. Mr…

govinfo.gov
Feb 28, 2024

Ranking Member Pallone and his staff have been very good to work with the majority staff on this bill, and I thank them for that. Last year, when I was given the opportunity to chair the Energy, Climate, and Grid Security Subcommittee…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation