Political Quotes

On the recordSeptember 27, 2007
I rise for a few moments because I know there are other people in this Chamber who have worked for many years on this bill who wish to speak. Senator Kennedy is here. I wish to take a few moments to rebut what was said about a half an hour ago. Our colleague from Oklahoma was making some arguments, and I want to rebut some of them. I know this has been a long debate, but it is important. He and others have made the claim about government-run health insurance over and over, and I think that is a White House talking point. I understand where they get the line. This is a program which uses private insurance carriers to provide the services especially to do the administration. So that argument really does not make a lot of sense. Secondly, he talked about shifting costs and people paying more taxes. It is very clear, just as the argument of our colleague from Kentucky made clear, that the increase in this program, the $35 billion to cover 4 million more children, comes from tobacco tax increases. We can have debates about whether it is right or wrong, but most people in America support an increase in the tobacco tax to pay for this legislation. We are not talking about an income tax or any other kind of tax. Thirdly, fiscal responsibility. We heard people talk about that issue today. No one on this side of the aisle needs a lecture from that side of the aisle or anywhere else about fiscal responsibility.
Said by
Bob Casey
Democratic · Pennsylvania

Editor's note · Context

Rebutting arguments against a health insurance bill during Senate floor debate.

Share

More from Bob Casey

Sep 12, 2024

Closing Sharon Regional Medical Center would have devastating consequences on the local community.

congress.gov
Aug 7, 2024

These are just a few, Senator Casey of the ways in which what we're hearing here is individual stories ladder up.

congress.gov
Aug 7, 2024

We are enormously grateful for leaders like Senator Casey who are working to make those investments a reality.

congress.gov
Sep 11, 2024

I hope that the Committee will be able to hear from him soon.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation