Mr. Speaker, this must be an election year or something. The Republican majority this year fancies itself a constitutional convention, so many constitutional amendments have come forward. The framers gave us a flawed document, but this was not the flaw in it. Why is two-thirds so rare in the Constitution for a presidential veto, for a constitutional amendment and for expulsion of a Member? Because the framers were democrats. They reserved minority power for fundamental rights only, not for everyday business of the House. This amendment would create a field day for lawyers: the 'de minimis' language in the amendment, for example 'De minimis' in relationship to what? Who is the majority afraid of? They control the House. Are they afraid they will raise taxes, like taxes on tobacco, for example, to save the lives of children? We are not smarter than the framers. I like the framework they gave us. Let's keep it.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the implications of proposed constitutional amendments during a House debate.
Share
More from James Norton
the local legislature, the Council, has 13 members. If D.C. residents do not like how members vote, residents can vote them out of office or pass a ballot measure. That is called democracy. Congress has 535 voting Members. None are elected…
I first came to Mississippi in 1963 in order to prepare for the summer of 1964 when students would come to the South and help the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee to register African Americans to vote in large numbers in the…
I rise and ask the House to support H.R. 6109, as amended, the Pre-Disaster Mitigation Act of 2008. H.R. 6109, the Pre-Disaster Mitigation Act of 2008, reauthorizes the Pre-Disaster Mitigation program for 3 years. The bill authorizes…
D.C. residents are treated as second-class citizens by Congress. They are required to pay Federal taxes, serve on Federal juries, and register with Selective Service in the same manner as residents of the States. They have served in the…





