The amendment meets the germaneness requirement of clause 7 of rule XVI. The amendment is germane because the amendment does not introduce a new subject of the text proposed to be amended. The subject of the introduced bill is applying certain requirements to drawdowns from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. The subject of the amendment also applies certain requirements to drawdowns. Again, Mr. Chairman, I have to stress that the reason that this amendment is germane is because we are trying on the Democratic side to seriously address the energy crisis and the energy future of this country. The Republicans are not doing that. They are simply using political points and trying to prevent the use of the reserve to actually help reduce the cost of gasoline at the pump. The CHAIR. The gentleman from South Carolina makes a point of order that the amendment offered by the gentleman from New Jersey is not germane. The bill prohibits the drawdown of petroleum products in the Strategic Petroleum Reserve until the Secretary of Energy has developed a plan to increase the percentage of certain Federal lands leased for oil and gas production. The amendment addresses sundry additional subject matters, including the Home Heating Oil Reserve, State energy transportation plans, and assistance for Western Hemisphere refineries. The Chair finds that the amendment goes beyond the subject matter of the underlying bill. It is, therefore, not germane. The point of order is sustained.
Share & report
More from Frank Pallone
I heard my colleague on the Republican side talk about the reduction in the number of pages in the bill. What I want to point out is by reducing the number of pages, which is not the issue, they reduced the help for the American people…
I thank the gentlewoman for yielding me time. Mr. Speaker, I rise in opposition to S. 2781. To be clear, I strongly support cleaning up abandoned mines, but this bill contains language that would undermine the cleanups it aims to support…
Have the Republicans forgotten that they are in the majority? The bill that was supposed to come up was posted and negotiated by the Republican Speaker. He posted it. He negotiated it. You know that the bill that you are bringing up…
In closing, I urge my colleagues to support this in the name of both Mr. Benigno and our colleague, Bill Pascrell, and I yield back the balance of my time.





