I think we should make a distinction between the insurance industry and HMOs and the managed care industry. There are a lot of health insurance companies that provide health insurance policies to individuals. They do not have the liability exemption that a managed care plan, an HMO, has when it is offered through an employer. Consequently, we see significantly fewer of these horror stories from that portion of the insurance industry. We see fewer reports of problems in the nonprofit managed care industry because they are ethically trying to do their job. When they look at a Patient Bill of Rights, as has been proposed by our legislation, they are already doing most of the things that we are proposing. What we are really talking about is a subset of the managed care industry that adamantly opposes quality standards. Why? Because they are cutting corners. That way they can increase their profit margin. Their stock will go up. Their CEOs will make millions more. They can capture more of the market share, because they are keeping their premiums lower than those plans that are actually trying to do a legitimate job.
Greg Ganske: “I think we should make a distinction between the insurance industry and HMOs and the managed care industry. There are a…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the differences between the insurance industry and managed care during a debate on health care legislation.
Share
More from Greg Ganske
let us get into the nitty-gritty of comparing some of the aspects of these bills. Mr. Chairman, I would make a strong argument that the Senate bill has stronger provisions in terms of requirements for screeners than the Young bill. The…
here is what two law professors from New Jersey say: ``In preempting State law, the Norwood amendment goes beyond conduct that involves negligent medical judgment to a particular patient's case. The amendment may, by virtue of the words…
In preempting State law, the Norwood amendment goes beyond conduct that involves negligent medical judgment to a particular patient's case. The amendment made by virtue of the words 'based on' stipulate that State malpractice law does not…
I wish very much that we had more time to see the language of the Norwood amendment so people could fully understand it. I intend to support the rule. I understand fully how my colleagues on the other side of the aisle very well are upset…





