Madam Speaker, this is certainly not the open rule that we had been promised, and while it is not entirely closed, we are all disappointed in the restrictive nature of this resolution for the consideration of a measure so momentous as an amendment to the Constitution of the United States. As has been well noted by the gentleman from Massachusetts, the history of the manner in which constitutional amendments have been considered, clearly shows that the use of the open rule is the wisest approach, and the one that appears to have been most often used when the threat of a discharge petition was not pending, as is currently the case. Even more disappointing, under this rule no perfecting amendments are allowed. If even a few of the proposed perfecting amendments had been made in order, we could have accommodated most of the major concerns about the legislation, and given Members of the House a chance to express their feelings on a number of very important additional issues--issues which are precluded from considering under this proposed rule.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the restrictive nature of a resolution regarding a constitutional amendment.
Share
More from Anthony Beilenson
I rise in opposition to all four proposals for amending the Constitution to balance the Federal budget. I share the feelings of frustration which have led many of our colleagues to conclude that amending our Constitution is our only hope…
If I may reclaim my time, the gentleman makes a valid point except to say, in fairness, I think the members of the Committee on Rules were not aware of the gentleman's problem or, in fact, that the proper gentlemen were not spoken to with…
Mr. Speaker, I rise in support of the rule on the foreign operations appropriations for fiscal year 1995. One of the amendments made in order by this rule is an amendment I shall be offering to increase funding for voluntary family…
yes, obviously many of the comments made by my friends and colleagues who seem to be supportive of the idea but cannot bring themselves to vote for it, most of what they have said is quite true. It does cut other programs, it does cut…





