Well, the issue was at least talked about by the Senator from Michigan. I do not know that the Senator from Michigan suggested this exact fix. He was at least in the room. I thought it was he who raised this question of quantifiable and nonquantifiable. Whoever raised it, we changed that definition so that benefit means identifiable significant favorable effects, quantifiable and nonquantifiable, so that you are able to use it, whether it is quantifiable or nonquantifiable, in meeting that test of cost-benefit. This is when you go beyond the quantifiable. You already quantified your benefits, but there will be other benefits nonquantifiable--the value of a life, the value of clean air, the smell of flowers in the springtime--all unquantifiable. That is what you can take into consideration, and we explicitly recognize that. You have already taken into consideration quantifiable, as well as nonquantifiable wants, but we are going beyond the statute at this point.
David Cay Johnston: “Well, the issue was at least talked about by the Senator from Michigan. I do not know that the Senator from Michigan…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the definition of benefits in relation to quantifiable and nonquantifiable effects.
Share
More from David Cay Johnston
The Nation has more than three decades of experience transporting both civilian and DOE-owned spent fuel. In 1997, 471 shipments were made, 444 of which were by truck. In the 1980's, 100 to 200 such shipments were typically made each year…
I am sending to the desk a sense-of-the- Senate resolution on behalf of the distinguished Senator from West Virginia, Mr. Rockefeller, and others regarding the United States-Japan semiconductor trade agreement which is set to expire on…
I rise today to speak to the merits of a program that has done great work in the field of medicine. The Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, or ATSDR, funded through the Environmental Protection Agency, has addressed the…
The point is this, though: They have tested it with weapons 30 times bigger than antitank weapons with direct hits. That caused a breach. Only a third of an ounce comes out. There are many, many much more lucrative targets, by orders of…





