Political Quotes

On the recordFebruary 2, 2012
Mr. President, I rise to express my concerns about amendment No. 1483 to the STOCK Act. While we all oppose public corruption and recognize the need for tough laws in this area, I believe this amendment may blur the line between innocent behavior and criminal public corruption offenses. This amendment expands the Federal criminal gratuities statute to cover the gift of anything of value, over $1,000, that is given to a public official simply because of their status as a public official. A unanimous Supreme Court in United States v. Sun-Diamond Growers of California interpreted the honest services law to require the government to actually prove a link between the thing of value given and the specific act. The Court said the thing of value must be given ``for or because of'' an official act. I am concerned that expanding the crime to include items given merely on the basis of the public official's status goes too far and criminalizes some legitimate conduct. However, my primary concern with this amendment is the section that gives the Federal Government the authority to interpret, prosecute, and enforce State and local laws. I believe this provision violates the basic principles of federalism embodied in our Constitution. Amendment No.…
Said by
Tom Coburn
Republican · Oklahoma

Share & report

More from Tom Coburn

Nov 18, 2014

Why should we not worry about that?

congress.gov
Nov 18, 2014

If we do not take care of our neighbors in West Africa, then we may see this deadly disease spread even faster across the world.

congress.gov
Dec 11, 2014

Mr. President, I submit the following notice in writing: In accordance with Rule V of the Standing Rules of the Senate, I hereby give notice in writing that it is my intention to move to suspend Rule XXII, for the purpose of proposing and…

Congressional Record · 2014-12-11
Sep 16, 2014

I just would say, Homeland Security's primary mission--one of their five core missions--the first mission is preventing terrorism and enhancing security, and that all fails if we do not have interior enforcement, and we do not right now.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation