Political Quotes

David Thomas: up until the last speaker, I thought we were doing pretty well focusing on the issues in front of us. A lot of people…

On the recordSeptember 30, 1997
up until the last speaker, I thought we were doing pretty well focusing on the issues in front of us. A lot of people think the census, and I quote from a letter that I got, the census is the only source of reliable, comparable, small-area data on income, occupation, and labor force participation, educational attainment, household structure, and other key demographic and economic data. And many Members have said, I think quite correctly, there is only one reason why we have the census constitutionally. It was that grand experiment the Founding Fathers decided to try: government by the people. Mr. Chairman, I know the gentleman, Mr. Watts, indicated and others propounded on, the fact that the actual enumeration in article I, is the manner by which Congress shall pose. I say, ``It's how you do it, not what you do,'' and I noticed every one of those individuals did not then turn to the 14th Amendment, as has been done on this side. After that great conflict it was determined that all people, I tell my friend and colleague from Georgia, that all people were to be counted, not three-fifths of a person, when all people were to be counted. The second clause of the 14th amendment says ``whole number of persons,'' ``whole number of persons.'' I noticed also that as the minority side propounded its constitutional arguments; that is, that it is constitutionally permissible to sample, I never heard the Supreme Court mentioned once.…
Said by
David Thomas
New York

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the importance of the census and its constitutional basis during a debate.

Share

More from David Thomas

Dec 8, 2006

That is boilerplate language that is used. This is something that we do virtually every year because there are always accounting errors, and this allows for the correcting of the accounting errors.

govinfo.gov
Dec 8, 2006

I appreciate people and their passion getting a bit carried away. This bill was signed into law by the last Democratic President, Mr. Clinton. It was on your watch. To stand in the well and tell us what is in the amendment that is going to…

govinfo.gov
Mar 27, 2007

I think this is certainly one of the most important bills we have had before us and one, frankly, that is the most time-constrained of any we have had before us. Normally, we have a good deal of time to talk about bills and we have budget…

govinfo.gov
Jun 22, 2006

I have a point of order. Beginning your statement with ``this is why it is germane'' is not addressing the germaneness question. The SPEAKER pro tempore. The gentleman must address his comments to the issue of germaneness of the motion to…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation