Political Quotes

On the recordAugust 3, 2001
as momentum builds for the deployment of missile defense and the abandonment of the obsolete ABM Treaty, those who oppose missile defense are getting more and more desperate in their arguments. One argument that we're hearing with more frequency is the threat of the suitcase bomb. This argument maintains that we shouldn't be spending our scarce defense dollars on ballistic missile defense when there are easier and cheaper ways a potential enemy could deliver a weapon of mass destruction to the United States. Rogue states could just smuggle a bomb in on a ship, or put it in a suitcase in New York, or drop biological weapons into our water supply. A missile defense system won't do anything to stop a suitcase bomb, so it must be a waste of money, or so the argument goes. This argument is repeated with such frequency, it might be useful to state for the record why it misses the point. Let me state the most obvious reason first. The presence of one kind of threat doesn't mean you shouldn't also defend against other threats. Imagine if this logic were applied consistently to our approach to national defense. Why have an army if you can be attacked by sea? Or, why have air defenses if you can be attacked by land? Such reasoning is absurd. If we refused to defend against one threat simply because other threats exist, we would end up completely defenseless.
Said by
Jeremiah Smith
Federalist · New Hampshire

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the importance of missile defense in the context of national security threats.

Share

More from Jeremiah Smith

Jun 19, 2002

I begin by thanking my ranking member, Senator Warner, and Chairman Levin for their outstanding work on this bill and achieving a compromise which would allow us to bring to the floor this legislation that would provide compensation for…

govinfo.gov
Jan 29, 2002

these amendments I have offered encompass a number of important issues, including property taxes, commuter taxes, tip taxes for those who work as waiters and waitresses for the most part, and Reservists. Those are the four categories. Mr…

govinfo.gov
Sep 5, 2002

I reiterate: This amendment trains and arms commercial pilots with a firearm to defend the cockpit of our Nation's commercial aircraft from acts of terrorism. The amendment also provides for increased training for flight attendants and…

govinfo.gov
Apr 23, 2002

As the Senators know, the compromise fuels package in the Daschle energy bill, which includes my language to ban MTBE and clean up the contamination caused by this gas additive, will also dramatically increase the use of ethanol. This…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation