Political Quotes

On the recordApril 14, 1994
Mr. Chairman, I would point out the inconsistency of my colleague's argument. Typically, he is the very person in this body who is talking against the delegation of authority that we should be exercising to the executive branch. There is nothing in the language in this bill which even requires the prosecuting attorney to tailor the aggravating factors in any way. There is not even any language that suggests that the prosecuting attorney must make it somehow appropriate, as he has characterized it. The prosecuting attorney could say the defendant got an F on his report card in the 10th grade and that could be an aggravating factor. He could pull any aggravating factor, unrelated to this offense, unrelated to anything else, that he wanted to pull and specify it. I would suggest, and I would ask my colleagues not to give that kind of discretion to prosecuting attorneys. We should not be pulling in prosecutors and giving them the authority to write the laws in this way. Additionally, the defendant deserves to know in advance the aggravating factors that will be considered. I would say that under this bill, given this discretion, the defendant will never be able to understand and know what aggravating factors will be considered.
Said by
Melvin Watt
North Carolina

Editor's note · Context

Discussing concerns over prosecutorial discretion in a bill during a committee meeting.

Share

More from Melvin Watt

Jul 11, 2013

On that I demand the yeas and nays. The yeas and nays were ordered. The vote was taken by electronic device, and there were--yeas 226, nays 189, not voting 19, as follows: [Roll No. 350] YEAS--226 Aderholt Alexander Amash Amodei Bachmann…

govinfo.gov
Nov 3, 2011

I was rising to claim time in opposition because I am opposed. But if the gentleman is going to yield me time. Mr. McHENRY. I'd be happy to let my colleague-- The Acting CHAIR. As a true opponent on his feet, the gentleman from North…

govinfo.gov
Nov 18, 2011

We didn't have a balanced budget amendment then. We acted responsibly, and not with a single vote from the people who are here lecturing us today and saying they need a balanced budget to stand behind. That's like standing behind my…

govinfo.gov
Jul 24, 2012

I just want to be clear that Mr. Frank and I both voted against the bill that you're talking about, so don't try to make it sound like it's Mr. Frank's and my bill. We voted against the bill. This is Ron Paul's bill. We thought it was a…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation