Political Quotes

Melvin Watt: In that section it says, ``The court shall only consider a claim under certain circumstances.'' I agree with the…

On the recordFebruary 8, 1995
In that section it says, ``The court shall only consider a claim under certain circumstances.'' I agree with the gentleman that this is not the standard for an ultimate disposition of the case, but it is the prevailing standard for determining whether one gets review or not. That standard was set out very recently by the court again in the case of Schlup versus Delo, January 23, 1995. This is the standard for getting a review. It is not the standard for determining whether somebody gets off or not. In that case, the court says, ``The standard requires the habeas petitioner to show that `a constitutional violation has probably resulted in the conviction of one who is actually innocent.''' That is the same language that I have picked up. So I just wanted to make sure that the gentleman understands. I am not trying to change the ultimate standard on which the person wins or loses. All this does is get the person into the courthouse so the court can evaluate the evidence.
Said by
Melvin Watt
North Carolina

Editor's note · Context

Discussing standards for habeas corpus review during a congressional debate.

Share

More from Melvin Watt

Dec 5, 2013

I am wondering, if you think this is redundant and extraneous rather than contrary to the intent, why wouldn't we just accept the amendment and keep going?

govinfo.gov
May 10, 2017

I took a lot of heat for reinstating it. But it was a statutory mandate, and I did not see a reason not to follow the statute.

congress.gov
Jan 26, 2015

There is nothing worse, I have found, in this area of the market than uncertainty, and the longer this drags out, the more uncertainty there is.

congress.gov
May 10, 2017

I think the 30-year fixed-rate mortgage has become a standard for American homeowners, and it is important to retain that.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation