Political Quotes

Melvin Watt: on a number of occasions during the 12 years that I have been in this body, I have risen on this floor to chide my…

On the recordJuly 22, 2004
on a number of occasions during the 12 years that I have been in this body, I have risen on this floor to chide my colleagues from the Committee on the Judiciary and my colleagues in the House for the arrogant and irresponsible belief that we are somehow smarter than the Founding Fathers, for the belief that process in the system and the form of government that we operate in is less important than the result that we seek on a particular issue. I think today is the ultimate irresponsible, extreme act in that direction. How arrogant and irresponsible is it to say to our American people that the United States Supreme Court will not have jurisdiction to decide the constitutionality of an issue? How extreme is that? It just blows my mind. I have trouble coming to grips with the notion that anybody could believe that this is responsible legislating, whether it is constitutional or not, that we would deprive the United States Supreme Court the authority to determine the constitutionality of an issue and disperse it to 50 different supreme courts of the States and not have one court that would be the ultimate arbiter of constitutionality. How arrogant and irresponsible can we be? That is exactly what this legislation does today. It says to the American people that the Supreme Court of the United States no longer has the authority to determine constitutional issues. How arrogant, how irresponsible can we be?
Said by
Melvin Watt
North Carolina

Editor's note · Context

Addressing the implications of legislation limiting the Supreme Court's jurisdiction over constitutional issues.

Share

More from Melvin Watt

Sep 26, 2018

I am a big supporter of the MeToo Movement. I think it is a wonderful thing, but it cannot be a substitute for going through the legal process.

congress.gov
Dec 12, 2013

This is definitely the last time I will be addressing this House. As my colleague, David Price, has indicated, I have been confirmed to a new position as regulator and director of the Federal Housing Finance Agency. I just wanted to take a…

govinfo.gov
Nov 12, 2013

As I have no further speakers, I urge my colleagues to support this bipartisan, commonsense bill, and I yield back the balance of my time.

govinfo.gov
Jan 26, 2015

Don't expect me to disregard the law and do it for you.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation