But the accomplishment by this Republic of its purpose to subjugate the Philippine people to its will, under the claim that it, and not they, had the right to judge of their fitness for self-government, is a rejection of the old American doctrine as applicable to any race we may judge to be our inferior.
Editor's note · Context
Hoar condemns the U.S. government's claim to judge the fitness of the Philippine people for self-government as a rejection of American democratic principles.
Share
More from George F. Hoar
Self-seeking political adventurers and demagogues have not been slow to take advantage of this feeling for their own purposes.
This Treaty would make us a vulgar, common place empire, controlling subject races and vassal states, in which one class must forever rule and other classes forever obey.
But I confess I like to leave on record, if I may, some evidence which will contradict the charge so constantly made by critics near home, that I am a man of intense partisan and personal bitterness.
But I cannot see it to be my duty to join in a secession from the Whig Party for the purpose of putting Mr.





