Judge Barkett, from every evidence I have seen--and I have gone through the record, I was there for part of the hearing--is eminently well qualified. The charge that she is soft on crime, or does not favor the death penalty--that really should not be a consideration. The reality is the soft on crime stuff just does not hold up under examination. And if someone happens to be opposed to the death penalty and is a judge, or favors some change, other change in the law, that judge is not there to make the law. That judge is there to enforce the law. She has indicated that she will do that. I think it is interesting the Orlando Sentinel concluded that the 'soft on crime' attacks by Justice Barkett's opponents are, 'reckless and unfair.' The Sun-Sentinel called the charges false. The Miami Herald concluded that the President, 'could not have found anyone better prepared.' The Orlando Sentinel called it a 'top notch choice.' The reality is this is a good nominee. I am pleased our colleagues, Senator Graham and Senator Mack, are supporting the nomination. I think we are making a mountain out of a molehill here. I think she ought to be approved, and approved quickly, and I hope we get on about our other business.
Editor's note · Context
Defending Judge Barkett's nomination and addressing criticisms of her qualifications.
Share
More from Sen. Paul Simon
I thank my colleagues, particularly Senator Kennedy, the chairman of the committee, and Senator Durenberger, who has been very helpful on this, as well as other things. We would not have the Direct Lending Program today but for Senator…
The answer is that we could, but the argument that my colleague from Michigan makes is precisely the opposite of the argument that we have been hearing over and over and over again on the floor. Some of my colleagues say this is too tough…
Yes, it is. If any such right currently exists under 42 U.S.C. section 1983, this Act does nothing to preclude such an action.
what this amendment proposes is very simple: That we appoint a three-member privacy commission with no more than 25 employees, $1.5 million authorization the first year that would take a look at the whole question of privacy in our…





