I think the great Senator Moynihan once said that ``people are entitled to their own opinions, but they're not entitled to their own facts.'' Allowing the immediate exploration on and under Oak Flat prior to NEPA review contemplated in section 4(j) of the act will constitute an irretrievable commitment of resources. That is part of what has already been the legislation. What's also in the legislation is section 4(c) of H.R. 687 that requires consultation only after enactment of the act, making any consultation with Native communities a mere formality. Secretary Vilsack said it in prior written comments: It is important that this bill engage in a process of formal tribal consultation to ensure both tribal participation and the protection of the sacred sites. This is his principal concern with regard to H.R. 687, and that's why it did not receive the support of the Department. I mention those things because they're part of the legislation. This legislation was written for the convenience of the company and to facilitate a trade that at the end of the day doesn't offer not only any benefit but circumvents any protections we have to deal with intended and unintended consequences. Mr. Chairman, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman from Michigan, Congressman Kildee, for his comments.
On the recordSeptember 26, 2013
Source
govinfo.govShare
More from Raúl Grijalva
Jan 30, 2024
We write to express serious concerns about the Mining Clarity Regulatory Act, which represents an unprecedented, de facto giveaway of America's cherished public lands to mining corporations.
Nov 19, 2024
This amendment, which I offered a version of at the markup nearly a year ago, would have addressed all the concerns. If adopted, I would be happy to support H.R. 1449. This amendment extends the timeline for the Department to determine…
Jun 25, 2024
The passage of this legislation would also set a dangerous precedent for sacred sites.
Mar 31, 2024
A few weeks ago, I sought medical treatment for a persistent cough which was initially diagnosed as pneumonia. After further testing and imaging, my physician discovered that I have cancer.





