I listened to the logic of arguments against the referral to the Judiciary Committee. It has long been a practice in the Senate when there are overlapping jurisdictions that you have sequential referrals to another committee. For some reason or another that tradition, that custom, that part of the Senate procedure just does not appeal to some of the proponents of this legislation. But it has been done historically. It is done because of the fact that a committee that has jurisdiction may not have all of the staff expertise to look into certain specialized areas. And the Commerce Committee, while it may have some lawyers, it is not like the Judiciary that looks into the legal aspects, the legal ramifications in regard to it. This is a completely new bill. There never has been a 15-year statute of limitation, statute of repose, that has been in a bill that has been before the Judiciary Committee. There have been statutes of repose but they have been different. This is much shorter. This would deprive a great number of people of the right to recover if they are injured negligently, or injured willfully or wantonly, or injured under any concept of recovery. It is entirely different and it is limited to that. Other times when you had referrals, you had referrals that were over the overall bill. Most of the time it was spent on other issues, like punitive damages, caps, joint and several, and other things other than just the statute of repose.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the referral of a bill to the Judiciary Committee during Senate debate.
Share
More from Howell Heflin
The Nation was shocked by the recent revelation that a 31-year employee of the Central Intelligence Agency, a man whose duties and responsibilities carried with them a solemn trust, would choose to betray that trust to a foreign…
the manager's amendment also includes a provision passed by the Senate last Congress to rectify a serious inequity in the current retirement system for Federal judges. This provision was included in S. 1673, and passed as part of S. 1569…
this is a managers' amendment by which we try to make a lot of technical changes. There are some issue changes that have come to the attention of the Subcommittee on Courts after the markup of the bill by the Judiciary Committee. The…
I will vote to confirm the nomination of Florida Chief Justice Rosemary Barkett for a seat on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. Having reviewed Justice Barkett's overall record--I emphasize ``overall record''--as well as…





