My colleague from Tennessee described a situation they have in their State--the same situation in South Carolina--where you can have a nonunion shop. People can choose to be in unions or unionize an organization. Workers can decide whether they belong to a union. What that is called is freedom. Those are basic rights of Americans. What my amendment would do is restore that freedom for people who live in every State, not just in States where State legislators have been able to overcome union pressure and reestablish that freedom. This is not about States rights, and this is not about the rights of the Federal Government. It is not about some Federal bureaucrats or what judges decide. Every American should have a right to decide whether they are going to join a union. For us to have a law at the Federal level imposed on people around the country that they have to join a union, they have to pay union dues, that employers have a right to fire them if they don't join a union--this is not good for individuals, but it is not good for our country.
On the recordJanuary 22, 2009
Said by
Douglas Alexander
Labour Party
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Discussing the implications of federal mandates on union membership during Senate debate.
Share
More from Douglas Alexander
Feb 12, 2009
Or to put it another way: Don't dump the water out on the street and fertilize the field if you need to throw it on the house.
Jul 17, 2026
By bringing this site back to life, the UK Government is also continuing its commitment to help with local recovery following the closure of Finnart last year.
Aug 19, 2026
You have about 30% of the Scottish population who now see voting SNP as both a habit and an identity.
Aug 19, 2026
One of the things that I think we misjudged in the May elections was assuming that because of the really poor governing outcomes that the SNP have had in recent years, that would have a dampening effect on their support and on their vote.





