Political Quotes

On the recordJanuary 29, 2020
Mr. Chief Justice, I send a question to the desk for both the President's counsel and the House managers. The CHIEF JUSTICE. The question from Senator Manchin reads as follows: The Framers took the words ``high crimes and misdemeanors'' straight out of English law, where it had been applied to impeachments for 400 years before our Constitution was written. The Framers were well aware when they chose those words that Parliament had impeached officials for ``high crimes and misdemeanors'' that were not indictable as crimes. The House has repeatedly impeached, and the Senate has convicted, officers for ``high crimes and misdemeanors'' that were not indictable crimes. Even Mr. Dershowitz said in 1998 that an impeachable offense ``certainly doesn't have to be a crime.'' What has happened in the past 22 years to change the original intent of the Framers and the historic meaning of the term ``high crimes and misdemeanors?'' It is counsel for the President's turn. Mr. Counsel DERSHOWITZ. Mr. Chief Justice, Senators, what happened since 1998 is that I studied more, did more research, read more documents, and like any academic, altered my views. That is what happens. That is what professors ought to do, and I keep reading more, and I keep writing more, and I keep refining my views. In 1998 the issue before this Senate was not whether a crime was required; it was whether the crime that Clinton was charged with was a high crime.…
Said by
Joe Manchin
Democratic · West Virginia

Share

More from Joe Manchin

Jun 6, 2026

It's broken. It needs to be fixed.

cbsnews.com
Mar 5, 2025

Lets put some respect back in and the dignity and decorum in the life of this great country of ours, lets be Americans first and put the -- put the country before the party.

transcripts.cnn.com
Dec 18, 2024

Let me just say that I think what happened is we have a bill that is hard to vote against. It really is. And I understand why there were 73 Senators who voted for it. Senator Cruz has had this and worked diligently for many years on this…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation