this is not an accounting debate, this is a debate about the future of this country. I believe that every American ought to get a tax cut, and the kind of tax cut that I favor is one that will not eat up so much of the surpluses that there is nothing on the table to strengthen Social Security or Medicare or strengthen schools or pay for a prescription drug benefit or fill in the gaps in health care and pay down debt. That is why I believe that there should be no tax bill on this floor until we have a full, complete budget so we can see the entire game plan. For this Congress to proceed with taxes alone before they have the other pieces on the basis of promises about what will happen to the economy 10 years from now is as irresponsible as the action that this Congress took in 1981. In 1981, this Congress roared through President Reagan's budget and said ``If you pass that big tax cut, we will have a balanced budget in 4 years.'' This chart demonstrates, the green bar shows the promises and the red bar shows the results. Instead of getting to a surplus, we wound up with $600 billion of added debt in those 4 years, and over the next 10 years we more than quadrupled the national debt. Mr. Speaker, that is the route we are heading down again if you pass this bill. Fooled me once, shame on you. Fall for it twice, shame on me. Fall for it four times, please, bring on the adult supervision!
David Obey: “this is not an accounting debate, this is a debate about the future of this country. I believe that every American ought…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the implications of tax cuts and budget planning in Congress.
Share
More from David Obey
When I came here, I don't think there were very many Members who would reach a conclusion that if someone disagreed with them on substance that somehow they were morally defective. In a civilized, adult, legislative body, Members would…
There is one difference between my friends over here who are speechifying against health care reform today and 50 million Americans. The difference is that the roughly 15 Americans over here all have health insurance, and it is largely…
As was pointed out earlier, those who suggest that any efforts to add any items to what is called a military supplemental are somehow out of line are simply wrong. This legislation started out as a disaster relief bill. It went to the…
41 years ago my friend and mentor, Wisconsin Senator Gaylord Nelson, had a surprisingly simple idea. At the time, the country was fighting an unpopular and unwinnable war, and students were rising up in protest and holding teach-ins on…





