Mr. Chairman, in light of the comments of the last speaker, I would simply note that the purpose of the Constitution is not to protect the guilty. The purpose is to protect the innocent. What we are talking about here is the power of agents of the government to search the homes of American citizens and to seize the property of American citizens, and the amendment offered by the gentleman from North Carolina gives us an opportunity to choose between the language of H.R. 666 drafted by the gentleman from Florida or the language reflecting the fourth amendment of the Constitution of the United States drafted by Thomas Jefferson and James Madison. I know it is a close call, but, pardon me, I am going to stick with the old fellows. I would also like to remind Members, in light of the comments made by the previous speaker, of the words of Sir Thomas More in the play 'A Man for All Seasons.' More was having a discussion with his son-in-law about the power of the king and the power of law, and his son-in-law said, 'I would strike down every law in England to get at the devil.' To which Sir Thomas More replied, 'And when the devil turned round on you the laws all being flat, where would you be then?'
David Obey: “Mr. Chairman, in light of the comments of the last speaker, I would simply note that the purpose of the Constitution is…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the importance of constitutional protections against government overreach.
Share
More from David Obey
I largely agree with my friend from Oklahoma. We have one simple dilemma: both in the case of the Cobell settlement and the Pigford settlement, the administration has asked us to provide the money. We do not yet have an understanding of…
I have the highest respect and appreciation for our troops who have done everything asked of them, but they are being let down by the inability of the governments of Afghanistan and, in some instances, Pakistan to do their parts. I would…
I want to thank the Members on both sides of the aisle for their courtesies over the past 42 years, and I want to say that it has been a privilege for each and every one of us, whether we have served here one term or 21 or even more, it is…
Somehow we are being told that we are committing a mortal sin because we are trying to attach some material to the bill sent to us by the Senate. I would simply point out that just a few weeks ago, as the gentleman from Massachusetts…





