I take our advice and consent function very seriously and especially so when it comes to the confirmation of Federal judges who are given lifetime appointments. In our system of Government, with coordinate branches and separation of powers, that is our responsibility in the Senate. But once a Federal judge is confirmed, our role is concluded. I have voted to confirm some judges who rendered decisions with which I strongly disagreed and have voted against a few who have surprised me by turning out to be better judges than I predicted. Whenever I disagreed with a particular ruling in a particular case, after a Federal judge was nominated, examined and confirmed, I have not attacked that judge or tried to influence that judge's consideration of an ongoing matter. If we disagree with the result in a case, we can determine whether the law needs to be amended or new law needs to be enacted. If a judge decides a case incorrectly, the remedy in our system is through judicial appeal. Indeed, the reason the Founders included the protections of a lifetime appointment for Federal judges was to insulate them from politics and political influence.
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the Senate's role in confirming Federal judges and the importance of judicial independence.
Share
More from Patrick Leahy
On February 23rd of this year, Senators Schumer and Coburn and I wrote you a letter commending your decision to sever ties with the Council on American-Islamic Relations, CAIR.
I brought a lot of bills to the floor here. This will be the last one I bring to the floor of the Senate. But it is one that we have to act on quickly or we risk a government shutdown. This omnibus appropriations bill provides $1.7…
the Johnson amendment asks us to cede the power of the purse to public servants in the executive branch who are unaccountable to the voters. These public servants, dedicated though they may be, cannot possibly share the depth of knowledge…
I am worried that we are heading toward another unnecessary, manufactured crisis because our current government funding is set to expire in 8 days. So I want to take a moment and talk about how we got here, and the path forward. In fiscal…





