Political Quotes

On the recordJune 28, 2012
I thank Mr. Graves for leading the floor tonight on this very important matter. He joins me, I'm sure, in saying that we're all extremely disappointed that we have to come to the floor tonight and that the Supreme Court ruled today that the Commerce Clause does not support the individual mandate, but it may be upheld within Congress's power to lay and collect taxes. So what we have found today is that Congress cannot use the Commerce Clause to compel you to do something. But, instead, Congress can tax you into submission. It should have been crystal clear that the Commerce Clause, which grants power to Congress to enforce free trade pacts amongst the States, could not use that clause to regulate it. If Congress can force you to purchase a product, then there is nothing government cannot force you to do. This would have been a violation of your individual liberties as well as the constitutional doctrine of enumerated powers in which Congress is only given few and specific powers. As the Supreme Court's syllabus of this case states: The Framers knew the difference between doing something and doing nothing. They gave Congress the power to regulate commerce, not to compel it. Ignoring that distinction would undermine the principle that the Federal Government is a government of limited and enumerated powers. But the Supreme Court instead told us that Congress has the power to tax and tax and tax until you submit to it.…
Said by
Thomas A. Garrett
Virginia
Source
govinfo.gov
Jun 28, 2012

Share

More from Thomas A. Garrett

Apr 10, 2018

There's aid to the top and aid to the people, and I would submit that the American paradigm works only when the people exist in a nation wherein the people have the ability and the right to assert themselves.

congress.gov
Sep 26, 2018

These promises of fairness manifest themselves in the uniform distribution of poverty and suffering.

congress.gov
Dec 19, 2018

Someone please wake me up. I think I am having a nightmare. What if I told you that, in the Middle East now, there is a place where Christians, Muslims, Arabs, Kurds, Assyrians, Yazidis--women and men--all sit together at the same table…

govinfo.gov
Jun 13, 2018

We have an ability--and a responsibility... to be a check on executive power by virtue of speaking when we are in disagreement.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation