Political Quotes

Rob Bishop: That news, if I can get the time from the gentleman from New Jersey, is as amazing as the potential harm that this bill…

On the recordJanuary 19, 2010
That news, if I can get the time from the gentleman from New Jersey, is as amazing as the potential harm that this bill could do to all Americans that are there. We've spoken many times on the floor about the concept of the general welfare clause, which was not an expansion of opportunity for Congress. It was supposed to be a limitation. And I did at one time get a call--we spoke once on what was the interpretation of the general welfare clause--I got a call from a lady from Alabama after that, saying it was very eloquent, but these are all the things I like the government doing. And then she gave me a list of stuff. I said, Ma'am, you basically missed our intent. It was not the government can do these things; it is which level of government should do these things. Not every issue has to rise to the importance that Congress needs to do it, which would lead to another element of the Constitution that I think this Obama health care-Democrat-Reid-Pelosi, whatever you want to call it, is violating, which is Federalism.
Said by
Rob Bishop
Republican · Utah
Source
govinfo.gov
Jan 19, 2010

Editor's note · Context

The speaker discusses concerns about the implications of a health care bill on federalism and the general welfare clause.

Share

More from Rob Bishop

May 31, 2020

All of those legitimate questions are not going to be addressed in this Committee hearing today.

congress.gov
Jul 22, 2020

I am hopeful that more substantial progress to strengthen the power grid is forthcoming in the near future.

congress.gov
Nov 16, 2020

Instead of helping, it seems the Majority is more interested in putting fishermen's livelihood at risk in the name of faux conservation.

congress.gov
Oct 1, 2020

One final parliamentary inquiry. The SPEAKER pro tempore. The gentleman will state his parliamentary inquiry.

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation