They were not the same papers, they were not privileged, confidential documents of the order of magnitude that these are. Let me add, the Clinton nominee--this is a Caucasian, by the way, not a Hispanic. The Clinton nominee, William Bryce, who was confirmed to the Federal circuit in 1994, was an assistant Solicitor General, just like Miguel Estrada. But nobody asked for his memoranda from his time in the Solicitor General's Office. He is one of eight former Solicitor General Office attorneys who have been confirmed at circuit courts without disclosure of their memoranda. Why the double standard? Why do we do this to the only Hispanic who has ever been nominated for the Circuit Court of Appeals? And why are the Democrats doing this to this Hispanic man? Why are they being so unfair? We never did it. We wouldn't dare do it. The fact of the matter is, I don't think anybody who understands the nature of the Solicitor General's Office, and apparently some on your side don't seem to understand that----
Orrin Hatch: “They were not the same papers, they were not privileged, confidential documents of the order of magnitude that these…”
Editor's note · Context
Addressing the nomination of Miguel Estrada and perceived double standards in the confirmation process.
Share
More from Orrin Hatch
I thank my dear colleague for his kind remarks. I didn't expect them. I didn't realize this was going on until a few minutes ago. So I am grateful to him. Thanks for that. The PRESIDING OFFICER. The Senator from Pennsylvania.
I stand by everything I said during my questioning of Mr. Saul, including concerns about budget summary data.
the Finance Committee has worked with the Treasury Department to ensure proper responsiveness to committee inquiries. We are continuing to review these matters to determine what further oversight is required.
I just can't express my gratitude for the kindness of my dear friend from Pennsylvania. This means so much to me. I didn't even realize it was going to happen. I hustled over here, and there it was. I say to the Senator, I am grateful to…





