They were completely different documents. They had nothing to do with recommendations for appeals, certiorari petitions, or amicus curiae matters. No. They have never, ever been asked for before, to my knowledge, and they have never, ever been given, nor would they. By the way, there have been some limited documents given by the Justice Department in some nomination matters, none of them related to what were requested by the Senate Democrats in this matter. And there are only a couple of cases where the Attorney General did allow that. The other cases, they appeared to have been leaked by friends of Democrats at the Justice Department. So they were not given up by the Justice Department. We have more than made that case throughout this debate. There is no question about it. And it is just another phony argument. I do not blame my colleague from Nevada for not knowing that. But I think it is time to learn it.
Orrin Hatch: “They were completely different documents. They had nothing to do with recommendations for appeals, certiorari petitions…”
Editor's note · Context
Discussing the availability of documents related to judicial nominations during Senate debate.
Share
More from Orrin Hatch
on May 14, 2018, the Supreme Court in Murphy v. NCAA, 138 S. Ct. 1461, 2018, struck down the Federal prohibition of State-authorized sports wagering schemes. I was one of four original authors of that prohibition, the Professional and…
what can you say about a dear friend who has passed away? That he was brilliant? And supremely accomplished? That he loved family and church? And the law? And people from all walks of life? To say these things does not nearly capture the…
I am pleased Congress recently passed my bipartisan bill, the Amy, Vicky, and Andy Child Pornography Victim Assistance Act of 2018. This legislation will help provide meaningful assistance for child pornography victims to support their…
These tariffs cause American manufacturers and farmers to pay more to conduct business and consumers to pay more to buy these things.





