Political Quotes

On the recordJune 28, 2000
I am in favor of Medicare revision and all of the things that the previous speaker said. The problem with the Republican bill is they are trying make an insurance product out of a benefit, and one cannot do that. Insurance is a pooling of risk. When all of the claimants are beneficiaries, there is no pooling or spreading of risk. Therefore, it has to be a benefit. Put another way, if everyone's house burned down, we would not be able to purchase fire insurance in the private marketplace, simply because they would not be able to offer it. This is particularly true in the rural areas. Short of importing people into the rural areas, we do not have HMOs. We do not have satellite dishes because we think it is cool, we have satellite dishes because there is no cable TV in rural areas. There are no HMOs in the rural areas. Therefore, we have to have a defined benefit under Medicare if we truly believe in delivering a prescription drug benefit to the senior citizens, all of them, in this country.
Said by
John Tanner
Tennessee

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the need for Medicare revision and the challenges of providing benefits in rural areas.

Share

More from John Tanner

Mar 12, 2008

we have seen, as Mr. Boyd pointed out, an unprecedented amount of borrowing take place since 2001. No political leadership in this country has borrowed as much money as quickly as we have seen over the last 80 months or so. That's just…

govinfo.gov
Oct 2, 2007

The point of this is that our soldiers, sailors, airmen, guardsmen, marines, are not dying in the name of the Republican Conference or the Democratic Caucus. They're dying in the name of the United States of America. We owe them a unified…

govinfo.gov
Feb 13, 2007

I was on active duty during the Vietnam years. The problem here is not the troops; the problem is the competency of the civilian leadership that has gotten us into this mess. This resolution supports our troops and calls for a different…

govinfo.gov
Feb 13, 2008

Mr. Speaker, I want to commend the Federal response to the tornados that occurred in Tennessee. I left here early last week and went down to my district in west and middle Tennessee to view, with the Governor of our State and others, the…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation