My problem with the bill that is under consideration tonight is in the theory behind it. My family has been in the insurance business in Tennessee for over a hundred years, and the reason we have Medicare in this country is because in the private world of insurance, there is no way that a senior citizen 80 years old with heart trouble and diabetes can buy health insurance. That is why Medicare came into being. They still could not buy it if we did not have Medicare. So what we are trying to do here is put a square peg in a round hole in that this bill tries to make an insurable product out of a benefit for which there is no risk pool for the concept, the theory of insurance to work. Insurance does not work when every policyholder is also making a claim against their policy. By the very inception of this kind of protocol, every policyholder will be making a claim. It is simply not an insurable product. What we are going to wind up with, I am afraid, and we will be back here in a year if this passes and passes the Senate, is we are going to have a patchwork across the country of differing coverages, differing plans, differing copays, differing premiums, differing in every respect. Nobody will know for sure what they have got.
Editor's note · Context
Addressing concerns about a healthcare bill during a House floor debate.
Share
More from John Tanner
I was on active duty during the Vietnam years. The problem here is not the troops; the problem is the competency of the civilian leadership that has gotten us into this mess. This resolution supports our troops and calls for a different…
this rule embodies a fundamental principle of responsible stewardship of this country, and that is to live within our means and pay our bills. There are some folks around here who apparently don't believe the laws of arithmetic apply past…
I understand this or any administration's defensive posture when it comes to criticism of policy. And I understand the members of his party feeling the need to defend it. This interim report, ordinarily, I would be one who would wait until…
Mr. Speaker, I want to commend the Federal response to the tornados that occurred in Tennessee. I left here early last week and went down to my district in west and middle Tennessee to view, with the Governor of our State and others, the…





