Political Quotes

On the recordApril 6, 2006
I yield 2 more minutes to the gentleman from Michigan (Mr. McCotter) in order to steer the discussion away from religion and back toward economic literacy. Mr. McCOTTER. Mr. Speaker, I thank you; and before I steer on to that path, I would refer the distinguished gentleman to Pope Benedict XVI's encyclical because it shows where the government is involved in taxation for the purposes of, quote, unquote, leveling, which is trying to discern what is the proper level of material equality in a free society, that the compulsory act of government of taking that money from people and then expending it on someone's behalf vicariously is certainly not tantamount to the moral good in a virtuous society that is achieved by the individual donating that money directly to charity and engaging in the life of their community to help their fellow citizens who are less fortunate. But I am sorry, I will not continue to go down that path. It is also interesting, the gentleman talks about not wanting to have class warfare or class envy at the very time he engages in it. I find that disingenuous, and I will not do the same. At the end of the day, what I would like, I think, to help frame my debate is, what level of taxation is enough? What level is enough? What is optimum for your particular, I assume hypothetical, level of material equality in this country that would be dictated by the government's confiscatory tax policies and arbitrary policies in appropriation?…
Said by
Philip English
Republican · Pennsylvania

Share

More from Philip English

May 8, 2007

But, Mr. Speaker, I'd like to, for a moment, return to my prior topic, put my green eye shade back on and talk about the AMT and its potential effect on taxpayers. You know, one point that I hadn't had the opportunity to make earlier, was…

govinfo.gov
May 10, 2007

the motion to commit is very simple and self-explanatory, but at the same time, it is also very timely. It comes at a time when there are legitimate and growing concerns about the pending change in tax policy in America and how it might…

govinfo.gov
Jul 17, 2006

I am most grateful and delighted that a strong advocate of trade and fair trade has joined us tonight to speak out on the Oman Free Trade Agreement. I yield to the gentlewoman from Connecticut (Mrs. Johnson) on this point.

govinfo.gov
Jun 6, 2007

for those who question the role of religious expression and religious faith in our national history and in our public square, I rise tonight to read a nationally broadcast prayer that was read on D-Day, June 6, 1944, by President Franklin…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation