Political Quotes

On the recordNovember 5, 1997
It is stunning, but the IRS is the only place in the American system of law where a citizen is guilty until proven innocent. Traditionally, the taxpayer, when notified by the IRS that his tax payments failed, in their view, to satisfy his tax obligation, carried the burden of proof in demonstrating that his tax payment is accurate. The presumption is for the IRS and against the taxpayer. In my view, this is just plain wrong. This legislation addresses that issue. This legislation, which is based on the recommendations of the Committee on Ways and Means, Subcommittee on Oversight, creates 28 new taxpayer rights essential to restoring to the individuals a sense of fairness in their dealings with the IRS. In my view, the most important of these is a shift in the burden of proof from the taxpayer to the IRS in any court proceedings where factual information is disputed. Let me be clear about this. The taxpayer is still required to cooperate. The taxpayer is still required to provide the information which is in the taxpayer's control. But those taxpayers who do cooperate and who provide all the necessary information see a shift back in an appropriate way in the burden of proof. From my standpoint, this will dramatically restore fairness in this situation. Also, H.R. 2676 creates an independent citizen board to hold the IRS accountable for change.
Said by
Philip English
Republican · Pennsylvania

Editor's note · Context

Discussing legislation to reform taxpayer rights and the burden of proof in IRS proceedings.

Share

More from Philip English

Jul 28, 2006

Did the gentleman vote for raising the minimum wage the last time this came up in 1996?

govinfo.gov
Jul 28, 2006

So you voted for the chicanery then, and you are going to vote for it now. Congratulations.

govinfo.gov
May 10, 2007

the motion to commit is very simple and self-explanatory, but at the same time, it is also very timely. It comes at a time when there are legitimate and growing concerns about the pending change in tax policy in America and how it might…

govinfo.gov
Jun 12, 2006

I need to start my remarks with an acknowledgment of the extraordinary leadership that the gentleman from New Jersey has provided long in the House as a defender of religious freedom, and the topic before us with this resolution is one…

govinfo.gov

Other voices in this conversation