Political Quotes

On the recordJuly 27, 2010
I have sought recognition to continue the discussion of the erosion of the very important principle of separation of powers. Our Constitution was devised with three branches: article I, the Congress; article II, the Executive, the President; article III, the judiciary. A very important concept in the operation of our constitutional government has been the separation of powers to provide checks and balances. During the course of the past two decades, we have seen a substantial erosion of the power of Congress. Congress's authority has been taken away in significant measure by the Supreme Court of the United States, which has, in effect, entered into the legislative process by disregarding the finding of fact that the Congress has undertaken and changed the standard for determining constitutionality of legislation. There had been in effect the rational basis test which had been in existence for decades. But then in 1995, in a case captioned 'United States v. Lopez,' involving the bringing of guns onto school property, the Supreme Court overturned 60 years of precedent. In the case of United States v. Morrison, when the Congress had legislated to protect women against violence, the Supreme Court of the United States, in a 5-to-4 decision--as was the Lopez case, 5 to 4-- decided that because of the 'method of reasoning' of the Congress, the act was unconstitutional, notwithstanding a mountain of evidence, as noted by Justice Souter in his dissent.
Said by
Arlen Specter
Democratic · Pennsylvania
Source
govinfo.gov
Jul 27, 2010

Editor's note · Context

The speaker addresses the erosion of the separation of powers and Congress's authority by the Supreme Court.

Share

More from Arlen Specter

Nov 17, 2010

Regrettably, this Convention is not at the top of the list.

congress.gov
Dec 5, 2011

Well, you are the Senate. You decide how to proceed.

congress.gov
Dec 5, 2011

The Court is very ideologically driven at the moment, and I think the public needs to understand that.

congress.gov
Dec 5, 2011

I believe that if the Court were televised, there would be an understanding and an accountability.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation