Political Quotes

On the recordJune 9, 1999
I believe that using language that vague virtually ensures that a significant number of frivolous cases are going to end up going to juries--exactly what we fear. What will happen, companies will attempt to defend themselves, the judge will be offered a motion to dismiss, and the company will say: It is frivolous; we move to dismiss the case. The judge will look, and if this were the standard that were actually adopted, he would say: I don't know whether they identified the potential for Y2K failure. And we would, in fact, be igniting an additional round of frivolous lawsuits. A motion to dismiss under this standard will get by because it is so vague. With respect to the economic losses the Senator from Massachusetts has talked about and believes are inadequately addressed under our bipartisan legislation, in this bill we keep State contract and tort law in effect. The problem is that there are some who disagree, some who would essentially like to create torts out of these contractual rights where no torts exist.
Said by
Ron Wyden
Democratic · Oregon

Editor's note · Context

Addressing concerns about potential Y2K litigation and the implications of vague legal standards.

Share

More from Ron Wyden

Aug 11, 2026

My goal throughout all these hearings is to advance a fresh plan to reimagine the American health care system that makes good on the promise that health care is a basic human right.

wyden.senate.gov
Aug 8, 2026

If Congress passes this bill, members will be condoning the tariff chaos of the last year and a half – and inviting more.

theguardian.com
Jul 31, 2026

Today the Finance Committee took an important step towards common sense reforms that will protect taxpayers and modernize the IRS.

wyden.senate.gov
Aug 1, 2026

We want to stress that this is not the time for creating new or different criteria for accessing this critical funding to support initial attack.

wyden.senate.gov

Other voices in this conversation