Political Quotes

On the recordApril 26, 2001
Mr. Speaker, the Lofgren substitute amendment would provide an enhanced sentence for a violent crime that causes an interruption to the normal course of the pregnancy resulting in prenatal injury, including termination of the pregnancy. This substitute clearly must be opposed. First, the substitute ignores the injuries inflicted by violent criminals upon the unborn. It appears to operate as a sentencing enhancement. A sentencing enhancement is when you get attacked and the attacker throws you down and hurts your arm, your leg and your back, too. The attacker's penalties gets enhanced by the additional penalties done to the victim. But I challenge anyone to sit back and reflect on the loss they would feel if they were a pregnant woman who lost her unborn child or a relative of that woman. Would the loss felt be the same as the loss of an appendix or pancreas? I think not. Would you feel the same regret you felt for a bone if a bone were broken or a slipped disk in one's back? Surely not. The loss that a person would feel would be a distinct and a unique loss, and the criminal law should appropriately reflect that loss in a separate offense protecting the unborn children. It is our goal to protect them and the mothers in this instance. The law does not simply punish criminals. The law, and especially criminal law, embodies the judgment of civilized society.
Said by
Steve Chabot
Republican · Ohio

Editor's note · Context

Opposing the Lofgren substitute amendment regarding sentencing for violent crimes affecting pregnant women.

Share

More from Steve Chabot

Mar 29, 2022

I had the honor to serve 26 years here in the House with Don Young. There is an expression some of our Texans have about not messing with Texas. Well, with Don Young, you knew not to mess with Alaska. We butted heads on that several times…

govinfo.gov
Apr 5, 2022

Taiwan faces a very serious threat from the Chinese Communist Party and has for some time now.

congress.gov
May 18, 2022

I urge my colleagues to support this bill on both sides of aisle, and I yield back the balance of my time.

govinfo.gov
Feb 2, 2022

the vast majority of these folks are going to be out on our streets someday.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation