Political Quotes

Louise Slaughter: here we are again, considering the rule for the same unconstitutional bill. I must voice my grave concern with H.R. 760…

On the recordJune 4, 2003
here we are again, considering the rule for the same unconstitutional bill. I must voice my grave concern with H.R. 760, the so-called Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003. Today The New York Times says in an editorial, ``Partial Birth Mendacity,'' which means lie, that although promoted as narrowly focused on a single late-term abortion procedure, the measure's wording adds up to a sweeping prohibition that would, in effect, overturn Roe v. Wade by criminalizing the most common procedures used after the first trimester, but well before fetal viability. My constituents are facing unemployment. They are losing out on child tax credit. They need more funding for our first responders, they need the promised health care for our veterans; but here we are debating a rule on legislation that violates fundamental constitutional rights and threatens women's health. Mr. Speaker, 3 years ago the United States Supreme Court struck down similar legislation that banned safe and effective abortion procedures. They confirmed again a woman's reproductive rights as recognized in Roe v. Wade and reaffirmed 2 decades later in Planned Parenthood of Southeastern Pennsylvania v. Casey. H.R. 760 suffers from the same constitutional flaws as the Nebraska statute thrown out by the Court. The ban on medical procedures is vague and overbroad, and it does not contain an exception from the procedure ban when a woman's health is threatened.
Said by
Louise Slaughter
New York

Editor's note · Context

Addressing concerns about the Partial-Birth Abortion Ban Act of 2003 during a House floor debate.

Share

More from Louise Slaughter

May 15, 2017

Please, please do not let the NEA get killed. I feel like I have been begging you forever.

congress.gov
Jul 12, 2009

Fighting antimicrobial resistance is a key component of this kind of populationwide prevention strategy.

congress.gov
Dec 12, 2011

Oh, for goodness sake, last week we passed a bill worth hundreds of billion of dollars with less than a two-day layover and no one knew what was in it.

transcripts.cnn.com
Jun 10, 2009

I urge this panel to lend its support to this bipartisan effort so we can expose information that will inform future steps taken by Congress to improve pilot training practices and ensure passenger safety and confidence.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation