Political Quotes

On the recordJune 15, 2016
I have spoken on this floor many, many times against amendments--so far, futilely--against amendments to bar the transfer of prisoners from Guantanamo or to prohibit the expenditure of funds to move them here or anywhere else. This amendment is particularly pernicious. It says you may not spend any funds to move anyone from Guantanamo, period. That has to be unconstitutional, because what it says is, even if you find that an individual is innocent, even if you factually find out he is guilty of no terrorism, he didn't fight against us, he is not a prisoner of war, he is guilty of nothing, he must stay in jail forever. How can an American legislative body pass a provision that says we will hold someone in jail forever, not only without trial, but even if we know he is innocent of everything? I will make no further argument--I only have 1 minute--but the fact of the matter is it is clearly unconstitutional, clearly immoral, and against everything we should stand for. No one should vote for this amendment.
Said by
Jerry Nadler
Democratic · New York

Share

More from Jerry Nadler

Jan 16, 2025

Let's be very clear. Sexual offenses and domestic violence are serious crimes and are already grounds for deportability and inadmissibility, as they should be. Unfortunately, this bill is so poorly drafted that it would result in extremely…

govinfo.gov
Jan 23, 2025

I strongly oppose this legislation, which is not rooted in medical realities. Physicians do not abort babies after birth, period. Healthcare providers have always been legally required to provide appropriate care. Patients and providers…

govinfo.gov
Nov 19, 2024

We in Congress have an important job as a co-equal branch of the government.

congress.gov
Jun 22, 2025

The President’s decision to bomb Iran was grossly unconstitutional, since only Congress has the power to declare war.

thenation.com

Other voices in this conversation