A few minutes ago, four Republicans saved this House from disgrace. We almost passed a resolution to remove a Member from committees for the sin of exercising free speech. Charlie Kirk was a prominent figure, beloved by many, disliked heartily by others. If the First Amendment means anything, it means the ability to say anything we want, short of actionable libel, with respect to any subject. It even means, according to the Supreme Court in the Brandenburg decision in 1969, the ability to advocate violence except in a manner calculated to induce immediate violence. We forget the First Amendment at our peril. It is the keystone of our liberties, and we almost disgraced ourselves by traducing it a few minutes ago. I am glad we did not.
Jerry Nadler: “A few minutes ago, four Republicans saved this House from disgrace. We almost passed a resolution to remove a Member…”
On the recordSeptember 17, 2025
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Defending free speech and the First Amendment during a House debate.
Share
More from Jerry Nadler
Jul 17, 2025
A non-binding resolution—or any action that doesn't require the release of the Epstein files—is nothing more than a political smokescreen designed to shield Republicans who refuse to demand full transparency and accountability from the…
Sep 2, 2025
But I think a certain amount of change is very helpful, especially when we face the challenge of Trump and his incipient fascism.
Jun 22, 2025
The President’s decision to bomb Iran was grossly unconstitutional, since only Congress has the power to declare war.
Jun 29, 2025
If their operations are legitimate and above-board, why is there a need for anonymity, and why don't they need warrants to come onto private property?





