Jerrold Nadler actually said...

But who can determine that under what standards, and what precedents do we have?

My point was that however narrow or broad the basket, and I am not suggesting broadening it, you have to answer that question first--Are you...

I was simply suggesting that none of this makes any sense until you have determined that someone is an enemy combatant.

However narrow or broad the basket, you have to answer that question first--Are you an enemy combatant?--and have the procedural due process...