I want to make two points in this 1 minute. Number one, the gentleman who just talked disparaged the Supreme Court because of one decision, that we should not respect that decision. It is the same Supreme Court that 2 years ago arrogated to itself the right to take away from the American people the choice of the Presidency and said do not finish counting the votes, we declare George Bush the President of the United States. That decision has been respected. Though on the merits and on the intellect, that decision belongs in the garbage heap of history because it was not an honest decision, it was not honestly intended. It was a results-oriented decision. Secondly, the gentleman said that there are Members of this body who are not patriotic as seen by the votes against defense bills. The fact of the matter is, you can vote for a defense bill, you can vote against it based on whether you think that bill is best for your country or not. But to ascribe unpatriotic motives to differences of opinion is to disrespect the Bill of Rights in the Constitution. To ascribe unpatriotic motives to people who differ with you politically is the methodology of a Soviet commissar. It is not an argument that should be heard on this floor. It is an argument that destroys liberty. It destroys freedom of speech.
Jerry Nadler: “I want to make two points in this 1 minute. Number one, the gentleman who just talked disparaged the Supreme Court…”
On the recordJune 3, 2003
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Addressing criticisms of the Supreme Court and accusations of unpatriotism among Members of Congress.
Share
More from Jerry Nadler
Nov 19, 2024
While ORR does its best to care for unaccompanied minors, we know that the immigration system is broken, and that comprehensive immigration reform is needed.
Nov 19, 2024
We in Congress have an important job as a co-equal branch of the government.
Feb 12, 2025
I thank the gentleman for yielding. Mr. Speaker, I rise in strong opposition to H.R. 77, the so-called Midnight Rules Relief Act. Despite the bill's title, this legislation is not really intended to address midnight rules at all. Instead…
May 13, 2025
They rushed this cruel bill to markup in the dead of night without even understanding what they were voting on.





