this bill, which would ban legal abortion procedures, is deceptive, extreme, and unconstitutional. The bill has come before us time and time again with the obvious purpose that has been obscured behind the inaccurate and inflammatory picture. Do not be fooled. This is nothing less than an attempt to outlaw all abortion. The bill is so vague that no one is quite sure exactly what we are banning. The courts have not been able to determine it. Similar State versions of the bill are currently enjoined in 18 States. Doctors have testified repeatedly and courts across the land have found that similarly worded bans can apply to virtually all procedures used in the second-trimester of pregnancy and each to some first-trimester abortions. Why do not legislators try to simply ban all abortions, then? Because the American people would not stand for it and the Supreme Court would not stand for it. The proponents of this bill oppose all abortion. They oppose first-trimester abortion. They oppose pre-viability abortion. They oppose Roe v. Wade. They oppose health exceptions. They oppose simple-life exceptions. Some even oppose contraceptives. Just ask them. They represent extreme forces in this country and most Americans reject their rhetoric and their views. So what is it we have before us, then? A dead bill, a bill that is not going anywhere, a bill that has been defeated more times than the Washington generals.…
Jerry Nadler: “this bill, which would ban legal abortion procedures, is deceptive, extreme, and unconstitutional. The bill has come…”
On the recordApril 5, 2000
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Opposing a bill that would ban legal abortion procedures during a House floor debate.
Share
More from Jerry Nadler
Sep 2, 2025
But I think a certain amount of change is very helpful, especially when we face the challenge of Trump and his incipient fascism.
Dec 10, 2024
It's a gross abuse and ought to be investigated, although with Trump coming in, he's not gonna investigate it.
Sep 2, 2025
Watching the Biden thing really said something about the necessity for generational change in the party, and I think I want to respect that.
Mar 27, 2025
It is with a heavy heart that I rise today, alongside my colleagues in the New York delegation and many of our other cherished colleagues, to mourn the loss of a giant of the House and a trailblazer for women in public service, Chairwoman…





