in a few hours, the Senate will vote to proceed to the nomination of Michael Brennan to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. Mr. Brennan has not received a blue slip--that is a notice of approval that has been a tradition in the Senate--from one of his home State Senators, Ms. Baldwin. So the vote today will be a slap in the face to the custom of senatorial courtesy. It will be a slap in the face to the bipartisanship we hear so many on the other side of the aisle and so many more Americans talk about. It is blatant disrespect to every Senator who wants to withhold his or her judgment on a judge, a tradition that has been respected by Democrats and Republicans until Leader McConnell abruptly changed this earlier this year for circuit court judges. What makes this even more galling is the history of this vacancy on the Seventh Circuit. Mr. Brennan will fill the seat that had been held open by Wisconsin's other Senator for 6 years during the Obama administration. Well, how was Senator Johnson able to withhold? He didn't return his blue slip, and Senator Leahy, the Democratic chair, respected it. The same should prove true for Senator Baldwin. She should get the same respect from Senator McConnell and Chairman Grassley that Senator Johnson got for this same seat from then-Leader Reid and Senator Leahy, the chairman of the Judiciary Committee, but, no, our Republican colleagues keep changing the rules.…
On the recordMay 9, 2018
Share
More from Chuck Schumer
Aug 20, 2026
New York’s craft breweries, wineries, and distilleries are a cornerstone of Upstate’s economy, and I have fought for years to help these small businesses grow and reach new markets.
Aug 22, 2026
These new demands set an alarming precedent that is seemingly contrary to the Administration’s longstanding support for the privacy of U.S. citizens’ data.
Aug 13, 2026
It shows he is petrified of the questions a Democratic Congress will demand answers to. We will not let Trump escape the accountability he deserves.
Aug 14, 2026
As one of the most advanced and strategic military installations in the country, Fort Drum is ready, and the critical missions it carries out to protect our nation demand reliable, resilient, and independent onsite power generation.





