I will reclaim my time on that one. There are strong feelings on this side, as the Senator knows. It has nothing to do with games. To me, this rises to a sacred responsibility. And I don't use those words lightly. The bottom line is--again, I would first say to my friend from Utah, this is not a referendum on his stewardship on the Judiciary. It is, again, part of an extremely important process about who is on the bench, who is part of that third branch of Government and put there for life. But I would say to my friend--and he is the best in the business--the high dudgeon all of a sudden when a few nominees are held up for whatever reason and sort of the muted signs when he was chairman and many nominees were being held up, albeit not in exactly the same way--I would say it is a difference that doesn't make a difference; it is sort of, well, inconsistent. Again, that doesn't go to the personal integrity of my friend from Utah who did try in many instances but didn't succeed. And how we should be judged, so to speak, is by who gets on the bench and who does not because that is ultimately what the process is about. I would mention, in my colleague's recounting, there were lots who withdrew their nominations. You had the DC Circuit, the second most important circuit, for which both Miguel Estrada and Judge Roberts have been nominated, where there were no blue slip problems and there were no votes. So we can go over history.…
Chuck Schumer: “I will reclaim my time on that one. There are strong feelings on this side, as the Senator knows. It has nothing to do…”
On the recordApril 29, 2003
Source
govinfo.govEditor's note · Context
Discussing judicial nominations and the nomination process during Senate floor debate.
Share
More from Chuck Schumer
Aug 27, 2026
I’m proud to announce that USDA has heeded my call to purchase Concord grape juice. This is a win for Upstate farmers, families, and New York’s economy. I’ll keep fighting for our growers and a stronger domestic food supply chain.
Aug 21, 2026
West Kill deserves transparency and action, which is why I’m calling on the USPS to work with residents to immediately reinstate postal service in the town.
Aug 21, 2026
A nuclear microreactor would provide Fort Drum with a reliable, non-carbon polluting, independent, and continuous source of energy for mission-critical support functions.





