Political Quotes

Harry Reid: “If cloture is invoked, you can bring up a nongermane amendment, but if anyone raises a point of order that your…”

On the recordJuly 9, 2004
If cloture is invoked, you can bring up a nongermane amendment, but if anyone raises a point of order that your amendment is not germane, that amendment falls automatically. There is no such supermajority motion available like there is under the Budget Act. The amendment fails without a vote--fails or falls without a vote, however you want to term it. The only way you can get a vote is if you choose to appeal the Chair's ruling that your amendment is not germane. If you are successful, you will set a precedent that will permanently throw out the germaneness rule under cloture, and such an appeal of the Chair's ruling is a majority vote, not a supermajority vote.
Said by
Harry Reid
Democratic · Nevada

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the implications of invoking cloture on the class action bill and the rules regarding nongermane amendments.

Share

More from Harry Reid

Dec 28, 2021

Never in the history of the country, never in the history of the country have we produced more for a president and somebody that’s led his party than we’ve done together.

msnbc.com
Dec 28, 2021

I have to win 50 plus one.

msnbc.com
Dec 28, 2021

I didn’t have success because of my good looks, or because I was a genius. I had success because I worked harder than anybody else.

msnbc.com
Dec 17, 2022

I didn't make it in life because of my athletic prowess. I didn't make it because of my good looks. I didn't make it because I'm a genius. I made it because I worked hard.

nbcnews.com

Other voices in this conversation