Political Quotes

Byron Dorgan: “I certainly respect his view, but I don't share his view that this amendment would in any way be unconstitutional. I…”

On the recordMay 2, 2002
I certainly respect his view, but I don't share his view that this amendment would in any way be unconstitutional. I believe the amendment, if I modify it, would be less likely to achieve its purpose. If I don't modify it, I think it is a stronger initiative that says to the administration, this is what the Congress aspires to achieve with respect to changing the secrecy by which dispute tribunals in NAFTA are now conducted. I would prefer we not modify it in order that it be a stronger initiative. I do not see this as in any way being unconstitutional. It is in perfect concert with our constitutional responsibilities.
Said by
Byron Dorgan
Democratic · North Dakota

Editor's note · Context

Discussing the constitutionality of an amendment related to NAFTA dispute tribunals.

Share

More from Byron Dorgan

Jun 12, 2024

I just want to say that I am concerned about the court's decision in Carcieri and the impact it may have on those tribes that were recognized after 1934.

congress.gov
Feb 2, 2016

This is not about politics; everyone on this dais knows that.

congress.gov
Feb 2, 2016

It is a travesty! Further, it is a problem that will continue to have negative impacts for generations to come.

congress.gov
Jun 25, 2024

Tribes ceded close to 200 million acres of land during the treaty-making and removal periods prior to 1881.

congress.gov

Other voices in this conversation