The laws of human nature do not permit the supposition that twelve men, taken by lot from the mass of the people, and acting under such circumstances, will all prove dishonest.
Lysander Spooner: “The laws of human nature do not permit the supposition that twelve men, taken by lot from the mass of the people, and…”
Editor's note · Context
Spooner argues against the notion that randomly selected jurors will all act dishonestly.
Share
More from Lysander Spooner
They cannot claim or expect that the whole people shall practise the folly of taking on trust their pretended superior knowledge, and of committing blindly into their hands all their own interests, liberties, and rights, to be disposed of…
In that case the trial is really a trial by the government, and not by the jury.
It is also sheer impudence, on their part, to assume that their commands are at all necessary to teach other men what is, and what is not, justice.
The people are no more arrayed against themselves, when a jury puts its veto upon a statute, which the other tribunals have sanctioned, than they are when the same veto is exercised by the representatives, the senate, the executive, or the…