We're striking the findings. By striking statements of constitutional authority for the bill, the amendment recognizes that many Members of the House question Congress' constitutional authority to pass H.R. 5. So for that reason, my colleagues, the findings are all important. Supporters of states' rights ought to take the next step and eliminate the section of the bill that preempts State law. Indeed, many supporters of the underlying bill have spent years arguing that decisions about health care are fundamentally prerogatives of the State. So I have only 18 conservative or Republican scholars and leaders that agree with me, including the Heritage Foundation; the Virginia attorney general, Mr. Cuccinelli; the constitutional law professor at Georgetown Law Center; the distinguished Senator from Oklahoma, Mr. Coburn; some of our colleagues, including Judge Ted Poe of Texas, our colleague from Nebraska, Lee Terry, former judge Louie Gohmert, in particular, Ron Paul; the founder of the Tea Party Nation, Judson Phillips. It goes on and on, where we are all in agreement that the findings are, indeed, critical and ought to be left in the bill. To take the findings out is incredible because we say that the Federal Government shouldn't be involved, that it's a State matter, and tort law, itself, is a State matter.…
Share
More from John Conyers
I demand a recorded vote. The Acting CHAIR. Pursuant to clause 6 of rule XVIII, further proceedings on the amendment offered by the gentleman from Michigan will be postponed. Announcement by the Acting Chair The Acting CHAIR. Pursuant to…
In closing, I note that a broad coalition of public interest organizations, including Public Citizen, Americans for Financial Reform, the National Urban League, among others, strongly oppose H.R. 732. They warn: ``This measure would…
How much time remains on both sides? The SPEAKER pro tempore. The gentleman from Michigan has 2\1/2\ minutes remaining, and the gentlewoman from Georgia has 2\1/2\ minutes remaining.
How much time remains on each side? The SPEAKER pro tempore. The gentleman from Michigan has 11\1/2\ minutes remaining and the gentlewoman from Georgia has 10\1/2\ minutes remaining.





